A follow-up on last post’s G. K. Chesterton quote about the beauty of the pig:
After marveling at it, I read on to find that he goes even further. Chesterton writes,
“You can look down on a pig from the top of the most unnaturally lofty dogcart. You can examine the pig from the top of an omnibus, from the top of the Monument, from a balloon, or an airship, and as long as he is visible, he will be beautiful… In short he has that fuller, subtler and more universal kind of shapeliness which the unthinking… mistake for a mere absence of shape. For fatness itself is a valuable quality.”
Doesn’t that just terrify you? Doesn’t it bring up all the mumbling, grumbling, ad-supported ideas about what a terrible world we would live in if more people were fat, and what a horrible state of affairs it is if more people are fat? How it is all going to lead to early death, disease, and dysfunction? How could he have said such a thing?!
Well, I don’t know the context. I came across the quote in a lovely book, “The Good Good Pig“, about an actual pig and “the valuable, life-changing lessons [author Sy Montgomery] and others learned from Christopher Hogwood, a generous soul who just so happened to be a pig.” It notes that Chesterton was musing on his childhood dream of owning a pet pig, but that is all I know.
Of course, what the fatphobic wailing in the media fails to note is that there is nothing wrong with being fat.
Fat is something of a mirage in the first place. There is no dividing line between thin and fat, no point at which we can say we have crossed over. Like money, it is associated with worth – except that with fat, the less of it we have, the more worthy we think we are.
And as with money, there is no satisfactory endpoint – there is either the spacious territory of having a healthy relationship to money or our bodies, and living abundant lives, or there is the driving worry, whether quiet or loud, that we will never have (or lose) enough.
Fat is sometimes a symptom of an unhealthy lifestyle – compulsive overeating, or eating enough but very unhealthy things, or eating unhealthily and never, ever getting any physical exercise – but it is the unhealthy lifestyle that is the problem in these examples. There are people who are considered fat who eat healthily, exercise joyfully, and were born with a larger build. There are, of course, some folks with glandular imbalances too. But there are many people without a psychological or physical care in the world who are considered, by dressmakers or photographers or their anorexic-thinking neighbors, to be fat. The fat is not the problem.
This pig strikes me as laughing at us, and all our ridiculous obsessions with losing weight. What do you think? Is fatness ever a valuable quality? How can and should we associate worth with fat?





